Right of Reply

When I report on named people or organisations, I approach them before I publish and give them a fair opportunity to respond. This page explains what that means in practice.

When I approach

I approach before publication where a piece:

  • Makes a specific factual claim about a named individual or organisation that they could reasonably dispute
  • Attributes a decision, action or statement to a named person or organisation
  • Draws a critical conclusion about a named person or organisation

I do not approach for every mention. General descriptive references, commentary on matters already in the public record and routine contextual mentions do not normally require a pre-publication approach.


What I send

When I approach a subject, I will tell them:

  • Who I am and what I am working on
  • The specific claims or attributions I intend to publish about them
  • Where those claims come from (named sources and documents wherever possible)
  • The questions I would like answered
  • The deadline for response

I do not send the full draft of the piece, but I give enough detail that the subject can meaningfully respond.

Response windows

  • Standard: five working days.
  • Shorter where time-critical: 48 hours for a genuinely time-sensitive story. Shorter windows are used sparingly, and I will say why.
  • Longer where needed: where a subject needs additional time for a serious and substantial response, I will consider it.

A response window is the outer limit. Where a subject comes back earlier, I proceed as soon as I have reasonably considered the response.

How responses are incorporated

  • A substantive response that directly addresses my claims is quoted or summarised in the piece, fairly and in proportion to the claims.
  • A denial without detail is reported as a denial.
  • ‘No comment’ is reported as ‘no comment’.
  • A non-response (no reply within the window) is reported as ‘did not respond to a request for comment’, with the method and timing of my approach stated accurately.

I do not publish partial or selective quotations designed to mislead the reader about the balance of a response.


Post-publication right of reply

Subjects retain the right to respond after publication:

  • If I failed to reach a subject despite a genuine attempt, they can request a post-publication right of reply.
  • If a subject has new information or evidence that would change the account, they can raise it through the Complaints Procedure.
  • Where a post-publication response is material, I publish it: as a note on the piece, a stand-alone reply or a correction, depending on the content.

Questions or concerns

If you have been approached by Ennui Nation and have questions about the process, or if you were not approached and believe you should have been, email complaints [at] ennuination.com.